Integrative Approach to Probe Alternative Redox Mechanisms in RNA Modifications

ConspectusRNA modifications found in most RNAs, particularly in tRNAs and rRNAs, reveal an abundance of chemical alterations of nucleotides. Over 150 distinct RNA modifications are known, emphasizing a remarkable diversity of chemical moieties in RNA molecules. These modifications play pivotal roles in RNA maturation, structural integrity, and the fidelity and efficiency of translation processes. The catalysts responsible for these modifications are RNA-modifying enzymes that use a striking array of chemistries to directly influence the chemical landscape of RNA. This diversity is further underscored by instances where the same modification is introduced by distinct enzymes that use unique catalytic mechanisms and cofactors across different domains of life. This phenomenon of convergent evolution highlights the biological importance of RNA modification and the vast potential within the chemical repertoire for nucleotide alteration. While shared RNA modifications can hint at conserved enzymatic pathways, a major bottleneck is to identify alternative routes within species that possess a modified RNA but are devoid of known RNA-modifying enzymes. To address this challenge, a combination of bioinformatic and experimental strategies proves invaluable in pinpointing new genes responsible for RNA modifications. This integrative approach not only unveils new chemical insights but also serves as a wellspring of inspiration for biocatalytic applications and drug design. In this Account, we present how comparative genomics and genome mining, combined with biomimetic synthetic chemistry, biochemistry, and anaerobic crystallography, can be judiciously implemented to address unprecedented and alternative chemical mechanisms in the world of RNA modification. We illustrate these integrative methodologies through the study of tRNA and rRNA modifications, dihydrouridine, 5-methyluridine, queuosine, 8-methyladenosine, 5-carboxymethylamino-methyluridine, or 5-taurinomethyluridine, each dependent on a diverse array of redox chemistries, often involving organic compounds, organometallic complexes, and metal coenzymes. We explore how vast genome and tRNA databases empower comparative genomic analyses and enable the identification of novel genes that govern RNA modification. Subsequently, we describe how the isolation of a stable reaction intermediate can guide the synthesis of a biomimetic to unveil new enzymatic pathways. We then discuss the usefulness of a biochemical “shunt” strategy to study catalytic mechanisms and to directly visualize reactive intermediates bound within active sites. While we primarily focus on various RNA-modifying enzymes studied in our laboratory, with a particular emphasis on the discovery of a SAM-independent methylation mechanism, the strategies and rationale presented herein are broadly applicable for the identification of new enzymes and the elucidation of their intricate chemistries. This Account offers a comprehensive glimpse into the evolving landscape of RNA modification research and highlights the pivotal role of integrated approaches to identify novel enzymatic pathways.