Drivers and spatiotemporal patterns of post-drought growth resilience of four temperate broad-leaved trees

With the intensification of climate warming, more frequent and hotter droughts are a significant risk to forest ecosystems around the globe, including temperate biomes. To accurately predict the response of forests to drought, it is necessary to provide comprehensive information on the resilience of tree growth, its spatiotemporal changes and drivers. This information is often lacking for broadleaf species in temperate regions. To fulfill this aim, we analyzed 3177 ring-width series from 1981 trees covering 40 sites for four dominant broad-leaf tree species (Fraxinus mandshurica, Phellodendron amurense, Juglans mandshurica, and Quercus mongolica) in temperate forests in northeastern China. We quantified the resilience (resistance and recovery) of tree growth to extreme droughts. Minimum temperatures in most seasons and warm conditions and drought stress in early summer were the main factors limiting growth. Among the four tree species, Q. mongolica had the weakest growth resistance to drought and the fastest growth recovery from drought. Juglans mandshurica had a significantly (p < 0.05) higher drought resilience than F. mandshurica and P. amurense. Tree resilience presented a clear spatial pattern driven by differences in site condition and local climate. The resistance (recovery) to drought decreased (increased) with increasing latitude and longitude, and increased (decreased) with elevation. Q. mongolica exhibited a decrease in resistance and increase in recovery through time, whereas the other three tree species showed the opposite pattern. Fraxinus mandshurica, J. mandshurica, and Q. mongolica had high resistance (recovery) in warmer-wetter (colder-drier) regions. In contrast, P. amurense had reduced recovery in cold sites and low resistance in warm sites. The resistance and recovery indices of these sympatric tree species confirmed that different tree species have distinct strategies to cope with drought that is influenced by tree condition and local environment. The influence of biogeographical factors is often more important than other factors and should be considered when studying forest resilience to drought.