Collagen versus gelatin-coated Dacron versus stretch polytetrafluoroethylene in abdominal aortic bifurcation graft surgery: Results of a seven-year prospective, randomized multicenter trial

A prospective randomized multicenter trial was performed to compare knitted gelatin-coated Dacron bifurcation grafts, knitted collagen-coated Dacron grafts, and stretch polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) grafts.Between 1991 and 1998, 315 elective patients were randomized by age, gender, diabetes, runoff, indication (aneurysm, aortoiliac occlusive disease), and nicotine consumption at 3 centers of vascular surgery in Austria. The patients received gelatin-coated Dacron (GEL-D) grafts (n = 109), collagen-coated Dacron (COL-D) grafts (n = 100), or stretch PTFE grafts (n = 106).No intraoperative deaths occurred. The 30-day mortality was 3%. No difference was found between the 3 graft materials in long-term patency. The primary 5-year patency rates were 92% for GEL-D, 89% for COL-D, and 91% for stretch PTFE (P =.6001). The secondary 5-year patency rates also differed: 97% for GEL-D, 100% for COL-D, and 97% for stretch PTFE (P =.2062). Early occlusions were observed overall in 3% and late occlusions in 5% of patients. When both Dacron grafts were compared collectively with stretch PTFE, a difference was found in infection rate: Dacron 3% (6/209) versus PTFE 0% (0/106); P <.03.The bifurcation grafts of all 3 materials were comparable in primary and secondary patency rates, incidence of false aneurysms, and rate of perioperative complications. Graft infections were confined to the 2 Dacron grafts and did not occur in stretch PTFE grafts.