Enzymes, Manganese, or Iron? Drivers of Oxidative Organic Matter Decomposition in Soils

Oxidative decomposition of soil organic matter determines the proportion of carbon that is either stored or emitted to the atmosphere as CO₂. Full conversion of organic matter to CO₂ requires oxidative mechanisms that depolymerize complex molecules into smaller, soluble monomers that can be respired by microbes. Current models attribute oxidative depolymerization largely to the activity of extracellular enzymes. Here we show that reactive manganese (Mn) and iron (Fe) intermediates, rather than other measured soil characteristics, best predict oxidative activity in temperate forest soils. Combining bioassays, spectroscopy, and wet-chemical analysis, we found that oxidative activity in surface litters was most significantly correlated to the abundance of reactive Mn(III) species. In contrast, oxidative activity in underlying mineral soils was most significantly correlated to the abundance of reactive Fe(II/III) species. Positive controls showed that both Mn(III) and Fe(II/III) species are equally potent in generating oxidative activity, but imply conventional bioassays have a systematic bias toward Fe. Combined, our results highlight the coupled biotic-abiotic nature of oxidative mechanisms, with Mn-mediated oxidation dominating within Mn-rich organic soils and Fe-mediated oxidation dominating Fe-rich mineral soils. These findings suggest microbes rely on different oxidative strategies depending on the relative availability of Fe and Mn in a given soil environment.