The application of insulated gate bipolar transistors (IGBTs) in high-power converters subjects them to high-transient electrical stress such as short-circuit switching and turn-off under clamped inductive load (CIL). Robustness of IGBTs under high-stress conditions is an important requirement. Due to package limitations and thermal parameters of the semiconductor, significant self-heating occurs under conditions of high-power dissipation, eventually leading to thermal breakdown of the device. The presence of a parasitic thyristor also affects the robustness of the device. In order to develop optimized IGBTs that can withstand high-circuit stress, it is important to first understand the mechanism of device failure under various stress conditions. In this paper, failure mechanisms during short-circuit and clamped inductive switching stress are investigated for latchup-free as well as latchup-prone punchthrough IGBTs. It is shown that short-circuit and clamped inductive switching cannot be considered equivalent in the evaluation of a device safe operating area (SOA). The location of thermal failure of latchup-free punchthrough IGBTs is shown to be different for the two switching stresses.