A comparison of cell death mechanisms of antioxidants, butylated hydroxyanisole and butylated hydroxytoluene

Butylated hydroxyanisole (BHA) and the chemically similar butylated hydroxytoluene (BHT) are widely used as antioxidants. Toxicity of BHA and BHT has been reported under in vitro and in vivo experimental conditions. However, the mechanism of BHA-induced toxic effects in cells is unclear. In this study, the cytotoxic effects of BHA and differences in cell death mechanism for BHA and BHT were investigated in rat thymocytes by flow cytometric analysis using a fluorescent probe. We observed a significant increase in propidium iodide fluorescence in the population of cells treated with 100 μM and 300 μM BHA (dead cells). Thymocytes treated with 100 µM BHA showed increased intracellular Ca2+ and Zn2+ levels and depolarized cell membranes. BHA (30-100 µM) decreased non-protein thiol content of cells, indicating decreased glutathione content. Co-stimulation with 100 µM BHA and 300 µM H2O2 acted synergistically to increase cell lethality. Moreover, BHA significantly increased caspase-3 activity and the number of annexin-V-positive cells in a concentration-dependent manner, indicating apoptosis. However, BHT reduced caspase-3 activity and increased the number of annexin-V-negative dead cells, indicating non-apoptotic cell death. Our results reveal the toxicity of BHA could be attributed to increased levels of intracellular Ca2+ and Zn2+, resulting in an increased vulnerability of rat thymocytes to oxidative stress. In addition, we demonstrate that whereas BHA induced apoptosis, BHT induced non-apoptotic cell death in rat thymocytes. Therefore, these results may support the safety of BHA, but also demonstrate the importance of performing toxicity evaluation at the cellular level besides the tissue level.