A Prospective Study of the Diagnostic Performance of Photon-Counting CT Compared With MRI in the Characterization of Renal Masses

OBJECTIVES: The aim of this study was to assess the interreader reliability and per-RCC sensitivity of high-resolution photon-counting computed tomography (PCCT) in the detection and characterization of renal masses in comparison to MRI. MATERIALS AND METHODS: This prospective study included 24 adult patients (mean age, 52 ± 14 years; 14 females) who underwent PCCT (using an investigational whole-body CT scanner) and abdominal MRI within a 3-month time interval and underwent surgical resection (partial or radical nephrectomy) with histopathology (n = 70 lesions). Of the 24 patients, 17 had a germline mutation and the remainder were sporadic cases. Two radiologists (R1 and R2) assessed the PCCT and corresponding MRI studies with a 3-week washout period between reviews. Readers recorded the number of lesions in each patient and graded each targeted lesion's characteristic features, dimensions, and location. Data were analyzed using a 2-sample t test, Fisher exact test, and weighted kappa. RESULTS: In patients with von Hippel-Lindau mutation, R1 identified a similar number of lesions suspicious for neoplasm on both modalities (51 vs 50, P = 0.94), whereas R2 identified more suspicious lesions on PCCT scans as compared with MRI studies (80 vs 56, P = 0.12). R1 and R2 characterized more lesions as predominantly solid in MRIs (R1: 58/70 in MRI vs 52/70 in PCCT, P < 0.001; R2: 60/70 in MRI vs 55/70 in PCCT, P < 0.001). R1 and R2 performed similarly in detecting neoplastic lesions on PCCT and MRI studies (R1: 94% vs 90%, P = 0.5; R2: 73% vs 79%, P = 0.13). CONCLUSIONS: The interreader reliability and per-RCC sensitivity of PCCT scans acquired on an investigational whole-body PCCT were comparable to MRI scans in detecting and characterizing renal masses. CLINICAL RELEVANCE STATEMENT: PCCT scans have comparable performance to MRI studies while allowing for improved characterization of the internal composition of lesions due to material decomposition analysis. Future generations of this imaging modality may reveal additional advantages of PCCT over MRI.