Biological control of take-all in wheat by endophytic Bacillus subtilis E1R-j and potential mode of action

The bacterial strain E1R-j, isolated as an endophyte from wheat roots, exhibited high antifungal activity to Gaeumannomyces graminis var. tritici (Ggt). Strain E1R-j was identified as Bacillus subtilis based on morphological, physiological and biochemical methods as well as on 16S rDNA analysis. This strain inhibited mycelium growth in vitro of numerous plant pathogenic fungi, especially of Ggt, Coniothyrium diplodiella, Phomopsis sp. and Sclerotinia sclerotiorum. In greenhouse experiments, soil drenches with cell densities of 106, 109 and 1012 CFU ml−1 E1R-j reduced significantly take-all disease, caused by Ggt, in wheat seedling by 62.6%, 68.6% and 70.7%, respectively, compared to the inoculated control, 4 weeks after sowing. Growth parameters such as lengths and fresh weights of roots and shoots of Ggt-inoculated control plants were significantly lower compared to Ggt-inoculated and E1R-j treated plants. Field experiments in the season 2006/2007, heights of wheat plants in the Ggt inoculated plots were significantly reduced compared to the non inoculated treatments. Yield parameters such as kernels per head and thousand kernel weight (TKW) in inoculated control plants were lower compared to the other treatments. In the experimental year 2007/2008, independent treatments with the bacterial strain E1R-j and the fungicide Triadimefon reduced take-all disease in wheat roots by 55.3% and 61.9%, compared to the inoculated control plants. In this season plant height in inoculated control was significantly lower and also the yield parameters seeds per head and especially TKW were drastically reduced compared to the other treatments. E1R-j treatment alleviated the detrimental effects of take-all on grain yield parameters to a similar extent as Triadimefon application. SEM studies revealed that in the presence of E1R-j, hyphae of Ggt showed leakage, appeared ruptured, swollen and shriveled. Following root drench, strain E1R-j was able to colonize endophytically roots and leaves of wheat seedlings. While the population of the bacterial strain in wheat roots steadily increased from the second to the fourth leaf stage, in the leaf tissue the population of the strain rapidly declined. TEM studies also showed that cells of E1R-j were present in roots of wheat seedlings and effectively retarded infection and colonization of Ggt in root tissue; suppression of Ggt by E1R-j was accompanied by disintegration of hyphal cytoplasm. In addition, in the presence of E1R-j cells in Ggt-infected root tissue morphological defense reactions were triggered such as formation of wall appositions and papillae. The results presented indicate that the endophytic strain E1R-j of B. subtilis meets demands required for biocontrol of take-all.