Hunting for Quaternary Faults in Eastern Canada: A Critical Appraisal of Two Potential Candidates

Abstract This study documents two potential neotectonic features in the seismically active St. Lawrence estuary and western part of the Gulf of St. Lawrence of Quebec, Canada. Historically, the region is the locus of series of damaging earthquakes, including the 1663 M 7 earthquake, which suggests the occurrence of coseismic surface ruptures beneath the St. Lawrence River. In the western Gulf of St. Lawrence (Lower St. Lawrence seismic zone), a potential fault scarp identified on a vintage seismic profile has been investigated through high-resolution seismic and multibeam bathymetry data. On the seafloor, the scarp corresponds to an ∼1.8 m high (maximum) feature that is located above a buried escarpment of the Paleozoic bedrock. Holocene units are draping over the escarpment on one profile, but are possibly cut on two others. The scarp meets several of the criteria generally associated with neotectonic features. However, a close look at the data indicates that the staircase geometry of the top of the bedrock and its expression at the surface is linked, at least partially, with the presence of an erosion-resistant unit. This makes a neotectonic reactivation possible but not proven. In the Tadoussac area, ∼40 km north of the Charlevoix seismic zone, the offshore extension of the St. Laurent fault corresponds to an ∼110 m high bathymetric escarpment with well-preserved triangular facets. Such “fresh” morphology is unique in the St. Lawrence River Estuary and may attest to Quaternary displacements, yet other interpretations may also explain the unusual preservation of the escarpment. These two case studies illustrate the difficulty to unambiguously document Holocene fault scarps, even in the marine domain in which the sedimentary succession is generally continuous.