Unveiling Chiral Perovskite CD Signal Scaling: Discerning Authentic and Counterfeit Signals through Sample-State Analysis

Circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy is a well-known and powerful technique widely used for distinguishing chiral enantiomers based on their differential absorbance of the right and left circularly polarized light. With the increasing demand for solid-state chiral optics, CD spectroscopy has been extended to elucidate the chirality of solid-state samples beyond the traditional solution state. However, due to the sample preparation differential, the CD spectra of the same compound measured by different researchers may not be mutually consistent. In this study, we employ solution, powder, thin-film, and single-crystal samples to explore the challenges associated with CD measurements and distinguish between genuine and fake signals. Rational fabrication of the solid-state samples can effectively minimize the macroscopic anisotropic nature of the samples and thereby mitigate the influence of linear dichroism (LD) and linear birefringence (LB) effects, which arise from anisotropy-induced differences in the absorbances and refractive indices. The local anisotropic and overall isotropic features of the high-quality thin-film sample achieve an optically isotropic state, which exhibits superior CD signal repeatability at the front and back sides at different angles by rotating the sample along the light path. In addition, sample thickness-induced CD signal overload and absorption saturation pose more severe challenges than the LBLD-induced amplified CD signal but are rarely focused on. The CD signal overload in the deep UV region leads to the presence of fake signals, while absorption saturation results in a complete loss of the CD signal. These findings help obtain accurate CD signals by a well-fabricated optically isotropic sample to avoid LDLB and optimize the sample thickness to avoid fake signals and no signals.