不诚实
订单(交换)
主题(文档)
主题
质量(理念)
公共关系
工程伦理学
政治学
心理学
历史
法学
计算机科学
认识论
业务
图书馆学
工程类
哲学
课程
财务
出处
期刊:Interfaces
[Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences]
日期:1973-11-01
卷期号:4 (1): 20-27
被引量:5
摘要
The flood of professional publications, which presents an information crisis of the first order, has now begun to produce a second-order crisis in its evaluation. Most professions are inundated with new literature. As a result, only a few books get reviewed, and those that do are often reviewed poorly. According to a political scientist who recently kept score on reviews of his latest book, the malady has several aspects: (1) Books whose subject matter suit them for review in certain journals are not reviewed in those but in other journals that are much less pertinent to the topic; (2) The assignments of individual reviewers to books is haphazard and results in incompetent reviews; (3) The “non-review” prevails: reviewers peddle their own intellectual wares instead of discussing the contents of the book in question and (4) Outright dishonesty occurs: distortion and misquotation shade off into plagiarism. These are strong assertions whose general applicability may not always hold; however, the issue of reviewer competency and the quality of reviews is worth more detailed consideration.
科研通智能强力驱动
Strongly Powered by AbleSci AI