Abstract Mineral association is a major mechanism of soil organic carbon (SOC) persistence, and mineral-associated organic carbon (MAOC) is often assumed to be preferentially derived from microbial residues. However, whether mineral association consistently favors microbial-derived over non-microbial carbon across environmental gradients remains unresolved. Here we combined continent-scale sampling of 192 soils from 43 U.S. National Ecological Observatory Network sites, horizon-resolved profiles to 2 m depth, size–density fractionation, and amino-sugar biomarkers to test how the realized degree of mineral association, indexed by the MAOC/SOC ratio, relates to carbon source allocation in bulk SOC and MAOC. We show that MAOC does not have a fixed microbial source identity. MAOC was not uniformly enriched in microbial-derived carbon relative to bulk SOC: this enrichment declined as MAOC/SOC increased, while non-microbial carbon became progressively enriched. Soil depth and chemical weathering were the strongest predictors of these source-specific enrichment patterns, and effective soil moisture shaped contrasting depth profiles in humid and arid systems. Our findings reveal mineral association state as a source-selective filter, challenging a uniform microbial-dominance model of MAOC formation and linking pedogenesis, hydrology, and vertical transport to persistent soil carbon formation across environmental gradients.