We explored the unbearable costs of ChatGPT use on sustained creativity through a pre-registered seven-day lab experiment and a follow-up survey in a month. 61 college students participated the study and completed 16 different kinds of creative tasks, resulting in a substantial collection of 3302 ideas and 427 solutions.. Half of them used ChatGPT to generate responses while the other half completed the tasks by themselves. Our findings indicate a temporary enhancement in creativity levels with ChatGPT use, accompanied by an increasing convergence in ideas. Crucially, when ChatGPT support was removed from participants who had developed a dependency, their initially boosted creativity levels dropped back to baseline, while the trend toward homogenized thinking persisted. This study reveals the potential negative consequences of ChatGPT dependency: in the long term, rather than augmenting creativity, ChatGPT may inadvertently hinder the diversity of innovative thought. These insights underscore the need for cautious integration of AI in creative processes and highlight the importance of fostering genuine and diverse innovation in scientific research.