Comparison of different DNA binding fluorescent dyes for applications of high-resolution melting analysis

Different applications of high-resolution melting (HRM) analysis have been adopted for a wide range of research and clinical applications. This study compares the performance of selected DNA binding fluorescent dyes for their possible application in HRM. We compared twelve dyes with basic properties considered relevant for PCR amplification and melting curve analysis. These included PCR inhibition, fluorescence intensity, the ability to generate melting curves and their effect on melting temperature (Tm). Seven of these dyes with promising properties were then evaluated for possible use in basic HRM applications; such as small amplicon genotyping, genotyping of a 1 kb insertion/deletion polymorphism, probe-based genotyping and mutation screening. Five dyes failed to exhibit promising properties during the first part of the study, and these were excluded from further testing. Of the remaining dyes, SYTO11, SYTO13 and SYTO16 showed better PCR inhibitory and Tm affecting properties compared to commercial HRM dyes LCGreen Plus, EvaGreen and ResoLight. Although the SYTO dyes generally exhibited good discrimination powers in HRM applications, SYTO11 and SYTO14 gave low signal intensity and lower quality results. Our results suggest that the best performing dyes for HRM are those commercially offered for HRM analyses. However, the performance of SYTO16 and SYTO13 was comparable to the HRM dyes in the majority of our assays, thus demonstrating that they are also quite suitable for both real-time PCR and HRM applications.