Feasibility of organic micropollutant removal from municipal wastewaters by algal treatment vs. activated sludge treatment: Comparison based on non-targeted organic compound analysis

Sustainability and life-cycle concerns about the conventional activated sludge (CAS) process for wastewater treatment have been driving the development of energy-efficient, greener alternatives. Feasibility of an algal-based wastewater treatment (A-WWT) system has been demonstrated recently as a possible alternative, capable of simultaneous nutrient and energy recovery. This study compared capabilities of the A-WWT and CAS systems in removing organic micropollutants (OMP). Initial assessments based on surrogate organic measures and fluorescence excitation-emission matrix (FEEM) scans revealed that the A-WWT system achieved higher removals of organics than the CAS system. However, effluents of both systems contained residual organic matter, necessitating further OMP assessment for a rigorous comparison. A novel ultrahigh-performance liquid chromatography- Fourier transform mass spectrometry (UPLC-FTMS)-based non-targeted screening approach was adopted here for residual OMP analysis. This approach confirmed that the A-WWT system resulted in better OMP removal, eliminating 329 compounds and partially reducing 472 compounds, compared to 206 eliminations and 410 partial reductions by the CAS system. Mass spectra signal corresponding to some OMPs increased with treatment while some transformation products were observed following treatment. Higher OMP reduction in the A-WWT system with concurrent reductions of biodegradable carbon, nutrients, and pathogens in a single-step while producing energy and nutrient rich algal biomass underscore its potential as a greener alternative for wastewater treatment.