Contrasting mixed scaling patterns and mechanisms of nanofiltration and membrane distillation

Oriented towards the pressing needs for hypersaline wastewater desalination and zero liquid discharge (ZLD), the contrasting mixed scaling of thermal-driven vacuum membrane distillation (VMD) and pressure-driven nanofiltration (NF) were investigated in this work. Bulk crystallization was the main mechanism in VMD due to the high salinity and temperature, but the time-independent resistance by the adsorption of silicate and organic matter dominated the initial scaling process. Surface crystallization and the consequent pore-blocking were the main scaling mechanisms in NF, with the high permeate drag force, hydraulic pressure, and cross-flow rate resulting in the dense scaling layer mainly composed of magnesium-silica hydrate (MSH). Silicate enhanced NF scaling with a 75% higher initial flux decline rate attributed to the MSH formation and compression, but delayed bulk crystallization in VMD. Organic matter presented an anti-scaling effect by delaying bulk crystallization in both VMD and NF, but specifically promoted CaCO3 scaling in NF. Furthermore, the incipient scaling was intensified as silicate and organic matter coexisted. The scaling mechanism shifted from surface to bulk crystallization due to the membrane concentration in both VMD and NF. This work fills the research gaps on mixed scaling mechanisms in different membrane processes, which offers insights for scaling mitigation and thereby supports the application of ZLD.