摘要
Dear Editor, Fistula-in-ano has been recognized for millennia but its treatment is still far from being established [1]. Complexity of fistula and experience of surgeons continue to be important factors that influence final results. Currently, with improvements in imaging methods, perioperative care that allows outpatient surgery or a very short hospital stay in most cases, and development of sealants or plugs that contributes to less therapeutic aggression in complex fistulas, long-term outcomes are yet to be evaluated and little scientific evidence has been reported. Although there is a tendency in decreasing risks of postoperative incontinence, rates of recurrence have not altered substantially. It is important to identify patients who are at high risks of recurrence after anal fistula surgery. Mei et al. [2] performed an evidence-based Delphi consultation survey on surgical specialists to identify major risk factors that could be used in routine clinical assessments of patients who are planned to undergo surgical treatment to help to predict the risk of anal fistula recurrence. A consensus was reached on 14 statements on the risk factors for anal fistula recurrence in three domains: patient-related risk factors including associated colitis, inflammatory bowel disease and use of immunosuppressants; fistula-related factors including transsphincteric fistula, number of fistula, horseshoe extension, undetected internal opening, location of anal fistula, recurrent fistula, suprasphincteric fistula, and height of internal opening; and surgery-related factors including type of surgery, previous fistula surgery and surgeon. Treatment of complex anal fistulas is challenging as these fistulas tend to entail a significant portion of anal sphincters, rendering complete eradication of the fistula tract associated with a considerable risk of continence impairment. On the other hand, failure to excise the primary tract and its secondary extensions and to drain sepsis adequately may eventually result in persistence or recurrence of anal fistula [3]. It has been estimated that previous fistula surgery increases the odds of recurrence after further surgery by two to three folds [4]. While the exact cause of this observation is not clear, it may be explained by disturbed anatomy of perianal region after previous surgery and effect of excessive scarring and fibrosis which may render identification of internal opening, secondary branches, and associated abscess cavities technically challenging. This has been demonstrated in a recent study [5] on the utility of endoanal ultrasound (EAUS) in assessment of recurrent anal fistulas compared to primary fistulas. The sensitivity of EAUS in detection of pathologic anatomy of recurrent fistulas was less than that of primary anal fistulas. If recurrent anal fistula was shown to be a simple intersphincteric fistula, then laying-open of the tract with curettage of its bed is usually sufficient, unless the risk of incontinence was high, then a sphincter-saving procedure such as ligation of intersphincteric fistula tract should be attempted. In case of more complex anal fistulas, the portion of the tract lying outside the external anal sphincter could be laid open or excised, whereas the part traversing the anal sphincters warranted a sphincter-saving procedure. In the long run, these results can be applied to refine on preoperative risk assessment, and to provide a call to conduct studies using large multicenter cohorts. Not only are unambiguous definitions for each risk factor needed, but also a comprehensive, uniform reporting of risk factors and outcomes is necessary to provide optimal care for increasing number of patients with anal fistula. “Provenance and peer review Commentary, internally reviewed” Ethical approval N.A. Sources of funding N.A. Author contribution Lijing Guo: finish the manuscript. Bin Luo: review the manuscript and edit language. Trial registry number N.A. Guarantor Lijing Guo. Research registration unique identifying number (UIN) N.A. Declaration of competing interest N.A.