The online food delivery (OFD) market has become more matured and now the competition is not only about acquiring more users but is also about retaining users. Platform aggregators use a lot of monetary incentives to win patronage. Despite the fact that the empirical literature in retailing uses a monolithic construct to refer to both upfront pre-purchase promotions (such as list-price discounts, waived delivery fees) and delayed post-purchase rewards (such as loyalty points, cashback, service recovery vouchers), it is generally agreed that both types of promotions can be effective in boosting sales. This systematic review aims to combine the findings from 57 studies on Reward Timing indexed in Scopus to present the Reward Timing Framework to the digital retailing literature. We theorise that reward timing is a critical cognitive boundary that can switch between short-term utilitarian calculation and long-term operant conditioning. We combine four theories in the literature—technology continuance, habit formation, stimulus-organism-response, and justice theory to show that pre-purchase discounts lead to immediate transactional conversion, but create multi-homing risk and margin erosion ‘discount dependence’ risks for platforms. In contrast, post purchase rewards are based on reinforcement learning and relational reciprocity to create habituation, create synthetic switching barriers, and buffer service failures. This paper explores two main research questions: (RQ1) What are the underlying psychological mechanisms and behavioural outcomes of pre-purchase incentives different than those of post-purchase rewards in OFD ecosystems and (RQ2) What are the service, market, and consumer contingencies under which post-purchase rewards are effective in inducing platform stickiness rather than opportunistic multi-homing? We finish with a practical, managerial plan for moving away from the business of acquisition subsidies to reward systems based on retention.