The difference score (D) approach and the no-difference-score (ND) approach represent two ways for testing nonlinear congruence effects. A recent meta-analytic study indicated that the three nonlinear terms of the ND approach as a set do not explain additional variance over and above that accounted for by the two linear terms. Expanding on this novel finding, the present study explains why the ND approach is less effective for detecting nonlinear congruence effects and how the D approach can overcome the limitation of the ND approach. Specifically, when examining nonlinear congruence and incongruence relationships, the ND approach considers it as necessary that the three higher order terms as a set should explain incremental variance; this requirement may hide important findings. The D approach, in contrast, does not have this requirement and enables nonlinear congruence effects to reveal themselves. Through a re-analysis of the existing data used by Edwards (1994), this study demonstrates that after considering the D approach, nonlinear congruence and incongruence relationships appear to be much more common than what was concluded based on the ND approach. This finding has important implications for knowledge accumulation in P-E fit research.