Comparing AI-generated care plans with gold-standard care manager plans: a two-layer blinded pilot study

案例经理 医疗保健 护理部 医学 质量(理念) 综合护理 比例(比率) 患者安全 梅德林 数据收集 急症护理 质量管理 医疗急救 心理学 社会关怀 药方 卫生服务研究 技能组合 医学教育 项目经理 社会工作 家庭医学 长期护理
作者
Liis Puis,Kadri Oras,Aive Purason,Luule Vitsur,Diana Palumäe,Margit Aab,Elvi Link,Karoliina Hunt,Mann Randaru,Maret Moisa,Mart Kull
出处
期刊:International Journal of Integrated Care [Ubiquity Press]
卷期号:26 (S2): 089-089
标识
DOI:10.5334/ijic.icic26089
摘要

Background: and Aim: Large language models (LLMs), commonly referred to as artificial intelligence (AI), can assist care managers in preparing structured health plans by synthesising clinical and social data. However, their practical value and safety remain to be determined. This small-scale pilot study evaluated whether care plans generated with a general-purpose language model (ChatGPT-5, OpenAI, Plus subscription) were comparable in quality and safety to those produced by experienced care managers (specialist nurses or social workers). Methods: A paired-sample design was applied using data from 11 patients participating in an integrated care programme at Viljandi Hospital. For each patient, two plans were created: by care manager (CM-CP) and by the language model (AI-CP). Both plans were based on identical inputs—hospital discharge summaries, national e-health records, prescription data, and the holistic InterRAI assessment results. The key difference was that care managers had direct patient contact and performed the InterRAI assessments. All clinical data were pseudonymised before processing. AI plans were generated iteratively in ChatGPT-5 using standardised prompts, with each patient handled in a separate “chat”. A two-tier blinded peer review was conducted by three independent care managers (tier 1) and two internist physicians (tier 2), all experienced in care management. An independent investigator normalised all plans for structure and appearance to conceal authorship. Experts rated safety, structural completeness, practicality, level of individualisation, person-centredness, and integration of medical and social aspects using a five-point scale (1 = poor/unsafe; 5 = excellent/no risk). Results: Reviewers were generally able to distinguish AI- and human-authored plans (82-97%). Tier 1 reviewers (n = 66 total ratings) found CM-CPs mostly safe: 55 % of plans were rated risk-free and 21 % carried only minor risks. In contrast, AI-CPs included a notable share of critical or major risks (12 % each). Regarding specificity and individualisation, 100 % of CM-CPs were rated good or excellent, compared with 57 % of AI-CPs; one-third of AI-CPs showed substantial deficiencies. Person-centredness was rated excellent in 46 % of CM-CPs versus 30 % of AI-CPs. Tier 2 physician reviewers (n = 44 ratings) observed similar trends: 77 % of CM-CPs were free of risk compared with only 36 % of AI-CPs, which more frequently contained medication-related and self-monitoring errors. For specificity and individualisation, 82 % of CM-CPs scored the maximum of 5 versus 27 % of AI-CPs. Person-centredness achieved the highest rating (5) in 91 % of CM-CPs but only 23 % of AI-CPs. Conclusions: AI-generated care plans remain inferior to the “gold standard” plans produced by specialist care managers. Nevertheless, current off-the-shelf LLMs can create coherent structural frameworks and synthesise clinical information to create a decent care-plan. Without professional editing and physician validation, however, AI-generated plans introduce clinically relevant safety risks and lack sufficient individualisation. Future integrated-care workflows will likely combine AI-generated drafts with expert human review to enhance efficiency while maintaining patient safety and person-centredness. Further research with larger samples is required to explore the ethical, practical, and cost-effectiveness implications of such hybrid AI–human models in real-world care coordination.

科研通智能强力驱动
Strongly Powered by AbleSci AI
科研通是完全免费的文献互助平台,具备全网最快的应助速度,最高的求助完成率。 对每一个文献求助,科研通都将尽心尽力,给求助人一个满意的交代。
实时播报
刚刚
basaker发布了新的文献求助10
刚刚
Felix0917发布了新的文献求助10
刚刚
暴躁的店员完成签到 ,获得积分20
刚刚
1秒前
健忘星月发布了新的文献求助20
1秒前
1秒前
BALL完成签到,获得积分10
1秒前
2秒前
桐桐的应助被zyy采纳,获得10
2秒前
zz完成签到,获得积分10
2秒前
YZZ完成签到,获得积分10
2秒前
云淡风清完成签到 ,获得积分0
3秒前
海2026关注了科研通微信公众号
3秒前
123发布了新的文献求助10
3秒前
3秒前
buchi发布了新的文献求助10
3秒前
鸟嘴医生发布了新的文献求助10
4秒前
Eternity完成签到,获得积分10
4秒前
整齐的茗茗完成签到,获得积分10
5秒前
光年以北发布了新的文献求助10
5秒前
Zhang完成签到 ,获得积分10
5秒前
5秒前
Owen的应助被不辣的皮特采纳,获得10
5秒前
孤独的学者完成签到,获得积分10
6秒前
L_JIN完成签到,获得积分10
6秒前
沐子完成签到 ,获得积分10
6秒前
tingwaiwufengyu完成签到 ,获得积分10
7秒前
年轻初曼完成签到,获得积分10
7秒前
赵先生发布了新的文献求助10
8秒前
linhongwei完成签到,获得积分10
8秒前
9秒前
威武苑睐发布了新的文献求助50
9秒前
深情安青的应助被Zz采纳,获得50
9秒前
10秒前
nb完成签到,获得积分10
11秒前
甜甜甜完成签到,获得积分10
12秒前
永不言弃完成签到 ,获得积分10
12秒前
12秒前
Auriga完成签到,获得积分10
13秒前
高分求助中
(应助此贴封号)【重要!!请各用户(尤其是新用户)详细阅读】【科研通的精品贴汇总】 10000
拉伸高分子熔体中缠结行为的模拟和小角中子散射研究 1700
The World Atlas of Wine 9th edition 1000
奈特基础组织学:配套组织病理学(第4版)(Netter's Essential Histology With Correlated Histopathology) 800
八旗制度の研究 600
高分子基功能界面水蒸发材料与应用研究 500
外场增强的水汽发电研究 500
热门求助领域 (近24小时)
化学 材料科学 医学 生物 纳米技术 计算机科学 工程类 有机化学 化学工程 生物化学 物理 复合材料 内科学 催化作用 光电子学 人工智能 细胞生物学 无机化学 物理化学 数学
热门帖子
关注 科研通微信公众号,转发送积分 8186541
求助须知:如何正确求助?哪些是违规求助? 9574894
关于积分的说明 21838647
捐赠科研通 7784174
什么是DOI,文献DOI怎么找? 3434800
关于科研通互助平台的介绍 2559183
邀请新用户注册赠送积分活动 2481565