摘要
The purpose of this research is to examine the similarities and differences, in perceptions of resource management and landscape quality, between the resident peoples (RPs) and the park management staff (PS) of the Gir Wildlife Sanctuary and National Park (the Gir) in India. The premise is that understanding such patterns of perceptions provides a sound basis for a more participatory and comprehensive approach to landscape resource management. The research participants were 116 RPs and 53 PS. Qualitative interviews and photo preference surveys were used to collect data on resource management and landscape quality issues including ones on four hypothetical (subsistence, cultural association, biophysical habitat conditions, and biophysical diversity) constructs. 147 participants also rated 50 colored photographs on a five-point preference scale (1 = low to 5 = high). Triangulation of theories and methods increase chances of validity and explain the results which, in turn, shape recommendations and suggest future research directions. The results revealed similarities and differences between the participants regarding perceptions and values of the Gir, resource management policies and actions, suggestions for making improvements in future, and perceptions of landscape quality. Contrary to conventional belief, the RPs, like the PS, were aware and concerned about the resource conditions of the Gir. The PS's opinion was split on whether the RPs, especially the Madharis (local cattle-herders), are really beneficial to the Gir and whether they should be allowed to stay in it. In general, the PS had more differences of opinion with the RPs than the other way around. The RPs highly preferred the scenes which showed subsistence, cultural survival, and biophysical diversity related scenes. The PS preferred the scenes with biophysical diversity and improved habitat conditions more than the ones with cultural survival or subsistence related elements. None of them preferred degraded landscapes. The differences between the RPs and the PS respectively can be summarized as inclusive versus exclusive concerns, perception of the Gir as a mother versus as an ecosystem, and a multi-objective and multi-method approach to solving problems versus a mostly single objective and single method approach. However, there are also high degrees of similarity in the perceptions and suggestions given by the two groups of participants. This is especially true for the issues related to policy making and implementation processes and for resource use and development. Research results and implications are discussed and recommendations regarding resource management, landscape quality, and research and education are presented.