透视图(图形)
第二语言写作
活动理论
心理学
第二语言
语言学
教育学
英语作为第二语言
语言评估
第二语言习得
数学教育
定性研究
语言习得
社会学
理解法
学习理论
语言教育
语言能力
语篇分析
计算机科学
英语
行动研究
透视法
标识
DOI:10.1080/17501229.2025.2569481
摘要
This study employs Activity Theory to examine contradictions experienced by English as a Foreign Language (EFL) learners engaging with artificial intelligence (AI) in second language writing. A qualitative analysis of three EFL learners identifies four levels of systemic tensions: between authentic learning and AI dependency, learning processes and product improvement, AI-generated and traditional assessment standards, and AI-assisted writing practices versus AI-restricted testing environments. These contradictions reveal AI-assisted writing as fundamentally tension-laden, reflecting systemic rather than individual conflicts. Findings demonstrate three resolution strategies: boundary work, where participants delineate human and AI domains with varying permeability; reflective mediation, wherein learners triangulate between AI feedback, teacher standards, and personal judgment; and selective appropriation, through which participants integrate AI resources according to developmental priorities. These strategies represent sophisticated forms of learner agency that position contradictions as generative tensions fueling critical reflections on writing practices. The study contributes to theoretical understandings of human-AI interaction by illuminating how AI-generated texts function as boundary objects at the intersection of multiple activity systems with different evaluative standards. These findings have significant implications for AI literacy development and fostering productive human-AI collaborative learning in second language writing instruction.
科研通智能强力驱动
Strongly Powered by AbleSci AI