This paper uses meta-analytic techniques to assess the extant literature that empirically examines the relationship between the presence of a star employee at a firm and that firm’s performance. Framed by the resource-based view, an examination of 30 samples from previous studies in the star literature suggests an overall positive relationship that is moderated by how stars are defined as well as the type of organizational performance metric used in the study. Studies identifying stars based solely on performance criteria report stronger relationships between the presence of a star and organizational performance. Furthermore, analysis indicates that the relationship between the presence of a star employee and organizational performance significantly differs in magnitude depending on whether an operational or global measure of organizational performance is used as the dependent variable, suggesting that stars are able to appropriate some of the economic rent which would otherwise show up as organizational profit. These findings suggest study design is systematically impacting results and should be taken into careful consideration when executing future star research.