作者
Wanatchaporn Puttakul,Nuttavut Kantathavorn,Kanyanat Chotichavanrattanakun,Nicha Vetvitayavatana,Natrada Ounphamornlah
摘要
Abstract: Debate about uterine closure at Caesarean delivery often centers on layer count, although scar healing also depends on tissue handling, suture technique and material, operative context, and maternal factors. Layers describe anatomical repair planes, not the number of individual stitches. This focused clinical review asks whether true anatomical three-layer endometrium-sparing closure improves clinically meaningful scar outcomes compared with an optimized two-layer endometrium-sparing repair. We classified evidence as direct, near-direct, closely related, or indirect, without pooling biologically non-equivalent techniques. No completed head-to-head trial was identified. The closest randomized evidence evaluates a standardized closure package and suggests improved 6-month scar morphology relative to traditional double-layer closure; it does not test the independent benefit of a third anatomical layer. Component-level findings support precise reporting of endometrial handling, myometrial apposition, locking, bite geometry, tension, and suture material. Maternal and obstetric risk factors must also be considered; nutritional effects on uterine niche formation remain insufficiently established. Current evidence neither identifies a universally superior layer count nor demonstrates prevention of Caesarean scar pregnancy or placenta accreta spectrum by a particular closure strategy. We propose a trial comparing two fully specified, optimized endometrium-sparing packages with equivalent surgeon training and fidelity monitoring, blinded standardized imaging, symptom and reproductive outcomes, and prospective assessment of safety, feasibility, and maternal, operator, and center factors. This framework separates plausible healing mechanisms from demonstrated clinical benefit and defines the comparison needed to determine whether an anatomical third layer adds value. Keywords: caesarean scar defect, residual myometrial thickness, uterine niche, tissue-plane repair, surgical fidelity