A critical appraisal of the International Classification of Headache Disorders migraine diagnostic criteria based on a retrospective multicenter cross‐sectional headache registry study in youth

Abstract Objectives We used Cluster Analysis of Migraine‐associated Symptoms (CAMS) to critically evaluate current International Classification of Headache Disorders‐Third Edition (ICHD‐3) migraine‐associated symptoms criteria. Background Diagnostic criteria play a central role in guiding clinical trial inclusion, and therefore available treatments. Migraine and tension‐type headaches (TTH) are differentiated in ICHD‐3 by many headache characteristics, including associated symptoms. A diagnosis of probable migraine indicates some but not all features of migraine are met. Photophobia and phonophobia, or nausea and/or vomiting, are required to meet a diagnosis of migraine; however, CAMS—a model that describes associated symptoms across youth with headache—indicates that a broader range of symptoms contain information about migraine burden. Methods In this multisite retrospective cross‐sectional study, we evaluated ICHD‐3 migraine criteria. Youth aged 6–17 years with migraine (including probable migraine) or TTH were included in the analysis. We used CAMS to evaluate the migraine‐associated symptom criterion. With CAMS as a guide, we evaluated how changes to the migraine‐associated symptom criterion altered who met the diagnosis of migraine. Results Of the 9017 participants included in this study, 66.7% were female and had a median (interquartile range) age of 13 (10–15) years. Most participants had migraine or probable migraine (99.0%), and the remainder had TTH (1.0%). A sizable percentage (10.1%) of youth under the umbrella diagnosis of migraine were diagnosed with probable migraine because they did not meet migraine‐associated symptom criterion D; however, many in this group reported several non‐ICHD migraine‐associated symptoms. We explored alterations to criterion D based on CAMS. Allowing for photophobia or phonophobia re‐categorized 55.6% of youth as having migraine, though some only had one symptom. Including lightheadedness or lightheadedness and spinning re‐categorized 19.7% and 25.8% of youth with migraine, respectively, but all of those who were re‐categorized had at least two migraine‐associated symptoms. Conclusion The ICHD‐3 captures the most prevalent migraine‐associated symptoms; however, many youths with probable migraine who do not meet full criteria due to insufficient associated symptoms nonetheless experience multiple non‐ICHD migraine‐associated symptoms. Changes to criterion D should be considered for the ICHD‐4.