Drawing from signaling theory we investigate how the media as a signal receiver interprets firms’ CSR signals with varying degrees of strategic orientation. Strategic orientation (SO) of firms’ CSR initiatives (i.e., strategic CSR) characterizes socially beneficial activities that can also be strategically justified as contributing to firm performance. We argue that strategic CSR is a multifaceted signal including centrality, specificity, and visibility dimensions. The SO of a firm’s CSR initiative is conceptualized as a point signal, while the average SO of individual CSR initiatives in a firm’s CSR portfolio is a flow signal. We argue that the media interprets CSR point signals relative to the flow signals – both historical (average SO of a firm’s CSR portfolio) and comparative (average SO of rival firms’ CSR portfolios). Our key premise is that a high degree of SO in general and relative to both historical and comparative SO will be associated with increased media favorability. We tested our predictions on a sample of the 12 biggest oil and gas multinationals that announced 511 CSR initiatives in 2015-2018. While we confirm that strategic CSR signals are favorably perceived by the media, increasing SO of CSR initiatives relative to firms’ historical CSR portfolio decreases media favorability.