Trust is fundamental to initiating and sustaining social relationships, yet the psychological mechanisms underlying trust updating, the developmental trajectory of selective trust, and the broader societal consequences of distrust remain underexplored. In this dissertation, I bring together three lines of research to address these questions. In Chapter 2, I investigated how adults make decisions in repeated trust interactions with trustworthy and untrustworthy partners. Across two experiments with N = 187 adults, I used regression and computational modeling to show that without any prior information, adults efficiently learned about their novel partners’ trustworthiness and adjusted their own trust behavior accordingly, with immediate feedback playing a stronger role than individual characteristics such as risk preferences or generalized trust attitudes. In Chapter 3, I examined when and how children effectively distinguish between trustworthy and untrustworthy social partners and adapt their own trust accordingly. Across two studies with a total of N = 223 children ages between 6 to 11, I found that children also distinguished their partners based on experience, although they were less trusting than adults. Older children updated their impressions more efficiently, while a social prompt helped younger children become more vigilant about their trustworthy partners. In Chapter 4, I broadened the scope to examine real-world consequences of distrust, leveraging a large nationally representative survey to investigate firearm behaviors in U.S. adults. I found that generalized distrust was associated with higher likelihood for protective firearm ownership. Taken together, this dissertation makes important theoretical and methodological contribution to the field, providing insights into the psychological mechanism behind people’s economic trust behaviors, the developmental trajectory and prerequisite for selective economic trust in childhood and the broader implications of lack of trust in the context of firearm-related behaviors in the United States.