Comparing the oncologic outcomes of local tumor destruction vs. local tumor excision vs. partial nephrectomy in T1a solid renal masses: a population-based cohort study from the SEER database

Background: There are few large-scale analyses comparing local tumor destruction (LTD) or local tumor enucleation/excision (LTE) relative to partial nephrectomy (PN) for patients with T1a renal masses in terms of cancer-specific survival (CSS) and overall survival (OS). We aimed to compare CSS and OS after LTD versus LTE versus PN. Materials and Methods: Within the Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End Results (SEER) database (2000-2019), we identified patients with clinical T1a renal masses and histologically confirmed kidney cancer treated with LTD, LTE or PN. After 1:1 ratio propensity score matching (PSM), comparisons between the groups were conducted. Kaplan-Meier analysis and log-rank tests were used to compare survival in the matched population. Results: In the overall cohort of 3717 LTD patients versus 1993 LTE patients versus 26935 PN patients, 77.3% of LTD-treated patients and 74.4% of LTE-treated patients were over 60 years old, while only 50.3% of PN-treated patients were over 60 years old. PN was more strongly associated with CSS (hazard ratio (HR)=1.276, P <0.001) and OS (HR=1.112, P <0.001)) than was LTD, while PN was less strongly associated with CSS (HR=1.040, P =0.230) and OS (HR=0.888, P =0.002) than was LTE, not only in the PSM cohort but also in the subgroups of patients with a tumor size ≤3 cm and patients with a tumor size of 3.1-4 cm. Conclusions: In clinical T1a solid renal mass patients, LTD was associated with lower CSS and OS than LTE and PN, while LTE demonstrated noninferior CSS and superior OS to PN regardless of tumor size.