摘要
Understanding the origin and evolution of complex traits is a major goal in biology. Here, we addressed how cellular novelties translate to trait innovation in the context of explosive seed dispersal. We followed a comparative approach by studying seed dispersal in the Arabidopsis thaliana relative, Cardamine hirsuta. This plant is a widespread, ruderal species that uses explosive seed dispersal to successfully colonize disturbed habitats. We recently presented a mathematical model that explains the mechanism of explosive dispersal in C. hirsuta (Hofhuis et al., 2016). Here, we review the cellular innovations for the storage and rapid release of energy that underpin the evolution of this trait. The mechanism that we proposed for establishing pre-tension in the fruit depends on a particular cell shape in the exocarp layer. We analyze the phylogenetic distribution of exocarp cell shape in Cardamine species with explosive fruit, and other species in the Brassicaceae with nonexplosive fruit. We conclude that this was an enabling character for the origin of explosive seed dispersal, while a second character gain – asymmetric lignification of the endocarp b cell layer – was a driving character. Dispersal of the next generation provides a valuable opportunity for plants to move. This evolutionary pressure has resulted in an enormous variety of seed dispersal mechanisms in flowering plants (van der Pijl, 1982). Explosive seed dispersal is an example of autochory, where seeds are dispersed by a plant's own mechanisms, and is found in various angiosperm lineages including the genus Cardamine. Cardamine hirsuta uses an explosive mechanism to launch its seeds at speeds in excess of 10 m s−1 upon ballistic trajectories to land within a 2-m radius of the parent plant (Hofhuis et al., 2016). During explosive pod shatter, the two valves of the C. hirsuta fruit pod coil rapidly, transferring kinetic energy to the seeds to fire them away. We showed that differential contraction of hydrated tissues in the fruit pod generates this coiling. Moreover, we demonstrated that this coiling becomes explosive through a rapid change in secondary cell wall geometry. To gain a quantitative and predictive understanding of this mechanism, we generated a multi-scale model that reproduces explosive pod shatter using interactions between cell and tissue-level processes (Hofhuis et al., 2016). This innovation appears to have evolved only once in the Brassicaceae family, and here we explore the use of comparative studies to understand the origin of this trait. Comparing a model species, such as A. thaliana, with a close relative, such as C. hirsuta, provides the experimental tools to identify and compare genetic mechanisms that underlie trait differences (Hay & Tsiantis, 2016). For example, the explosive fruit pods of C. hirsuta and the nonexplosive pods of A. thaliana are very similar in morphology but differ in the lignification of secondary cell walls (SCWs) in the valve (Fig. 1). We used this difference to design a genetic screen for C. hirsuta mutants with less lignified fruit valves that resemble A. thaliana. We reasoned that such mutants would tell us whether this character was required for explosive pod shatter and what genes controlled this character. We identified less lignin2 (lig2) as a recessive mutant with less lignified fruit valves, similar to A. thaliana (Fig. 1). We found that the lignified endocarp b cell layer was missing in lig2 valves, causing the fruit pods to shatter nonexplosively, like A. thaliana (Fig. 1). The mutated gene responsible for the lig2 phenotype was the C. hirsuta ortholog of the DNA-binding protein BRASSINOSTEROID-INSENSITIVE4 (At5g24630; Breuer et al., 2007; Kirik et al., 2007; Hofhuis et al., 2016). This result provides novel insight into the genetic regulation of endocarp b cell development and its importance for explosive pod shatter. Altogether, our findings showed that the geometry of the lignified secondary cell wall, deposited asymmetrically in endocarp b cells of the fruit valve, is required for explosive pod shatter (Fig. 1; Hofhuis et al., 2016). Comparing pod shatter between the explosive fruit of C. hirsuta and the nonexplosive fruit of A. thaliana, allowed us to uncover the developmental and genetic basis for this trait difference. However, to understand how explosive pod shatter evolved requires placing this character in a phylogenetic framework. We found that the geometry of endocarp b SCWs associated strictly with explosive vs nonexplosive seed dispersal across the Brassicaceae (Hofhuis et al., 2016). Explosive seed dispersal evolved in Cardamine and all species sampled in this genus had the derived character state – asymmetric SCW geometry – similar to C. hirsuta (Fig. 1). Conversely, all sampled species with nonexplosive seed dispersal had the ancestral character state – symmetric SCW geometry – similar to A. thaliana (Fig. 1). Therefore, endocarp b SCW geometry appears to be a driving character for the trait innovation of explosive seed dispersal. Another important component of explosive pod shatter is the differential contraction of fruit valves. Specifically, the exocarp tissue actively contracts in length while attached to the lignified endocarp b tissue, which is inextensible (Hofhuis et al., 2016). This generates tension that is released by the valves coiling. We developed a mechanical model that recapitulated this active contraction of the exocarp, and found that the three-dimensional shape of these cells was critical for contraction (Hofhuis et al., 2016). To understand how exocarp cell shape mapped on a phylogeny of the Brassicaceae, we imaged the top view of exocarp cells of mature fruit from 21 species (Fig. 2). We sampled five Cardamine species with explosive pod shatter and found a square cell shape in the exocarp of all species, similar to C. hirsuta (Fig. 2). However, we found that the exocarp of some other species with nonexplosive seed dispersal also had a square cell shape (Fig. 2). These included species sampled from the Cardamineae tribe, such as Nasturtium officinale and Leavenworthia alabamica, which indicates that this character evolved before explosive seed dispersal (Fig. 2). We also found square endocarp cells in the siliques of the more distantly related species Physaria fendleri and Pseudoturritis turrita, indicating that this character evolved independently outside of the Cardamineae tribe (Fig. 2). Moreover, we found that exocarp cell shape varied among nonexplosive Brassicaceae species. Elongated siliques usually had elongated cells, similar to A. thaliana, and short, broad silicles had lobed/jigsaw puzzle-shaped cells, such as in Capsella grandiflora (Fig. 2). Therefore, the square cell shape required for active tissue contraction is invariably present in Cardamine and likely enabled the innovation of explosive seed dispersal, but did not drive it (Fig. 3). By contrast, the gain of an asymmetric SCW geometry in endocarp b cells is likely to be the character that drove trait innovation (Fig. 3). Comparisons made at different evolutionary scales are useful to understand how a trait arose and evolved. The experimental tractability of A. thaliana and C. hirsuta, including genetic tools and reference genome sequences (The Arabidopsis Genome Initiative, 2000; Hay et al., 2014; Gan et al., 2016), provides an excellent comparative system to investigate the cellular and genetic basis for trait differences (Hay & Tsiantis, 2006; Barkoulas et al., 2008; Vlad et al., 2014; Rast-Somssich et al., 2015; Hofhuis et al., 2016; Vuolo et al., 2016). Placing such characters in a phylogenetic context further aids our understanding of how trait differences evolved. Here, we found that two cellular innovations required for explosive seed dispersal associated differently with the appearance of this trait in Cardamine. Asymmetric SCW geometry in endocarp b cells associated strictly with the evolution of explosive seed dispersal (Fig. 3), suggesting that genes regulating SCW synthesis and patterning in this cell layer are likely targets of evolutionary modification. By contrast, species belonging to the Cardamineae tribe all had square rather than elongated cells in the fruit exocarp regardless of their mode of seed dispersal, suggesting that this character enabled, but did not drive, explosive seed dispersal (Fig. 3). The variation in exocarp cell shape in nonexplosive fruit pods (Fig. 2) indicates that this character alone is not sufficient to cause tissue contraction and consequent coiling of the pod. Based on our mechanical model, we predict that anisotropic cell wall properties in the exocarp are additionally required, together with three-dimensional cell shape, to produce tissue contraction (Hofhuis et al., 2016). Future work will determine whether this combination of cellular innovations is sufficient to establish tension in the fruit pod. In summary, functional genetic studies, interpreted in an explicit phylogenetic framework, provide a useful path to study the evolution of morphological novelties. The authors thank L. Nikolov for critical comments and assistance with the Brassicaceae phylogeny, and together with K. Schneeberger and C. Kiefer for sharing plant material. This work was supported by BBSRC grant BB/H01313X/1 and HFSP young investigator's grant RGY0087/2011. A.H. was supported by a Royal Society University Research Fellowship and a Max Planck Society Minerva Fellowship.