烟草控制
内容分析
控制(管理)
广告
环境卫生
公共卫生
心理学
烟草使用
互联网隐私
社会化媒体
业务
统计分析
作者
Seda Özmen Sever,Saliha Büşra Aksu,Yağmur Gökseven,Güzin Zeren Öztürk
摘要
INTRODUCTIONYouTube is widely used as a source of health information; however, the accuracy, reliability, and quality of user-generated content vary considerably.Although e-cigarette-related videos on YouTube may influence individuals' health-related decisions and their perceptions and attitudes toward e-cigarettes, differences in the characteristics of this content across time periods remain insufficiently understood.This study aimed to compare content stance, provision of useful information, reliability, and quality of e-cigarette-and vaping-related YouTube videos uploaded before and after the COVID-19 pandemic and identify video characteristics independently associated with useful information.METHODS In this comparative cross-sectional content analysis, 400 videos were retrieved using the keywords 'e-cigarette' and 'vaping', were screened for eligibility, and 240 eligible videos were evaluated.Videos were classified by main topic, uploader category, and content stance and information provision.Reliability and overall quality were assessed using the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA) benchmark criteria and Global Quality Score (GQS).Multivariable logistic regression analysis identified factors independently associated with useful information. RESULTSThe proportion of videos providing useful information was lower in the post-pandemic period than in the pre-pandemic period (p=0.001).JAMA category distributions differed significantly between periods (p=0.019), with low JAMA category videos more frequent in the post-pandemic period.Videos uploaded by personal users (p<0.001) and those featuring personal experience, entertainment, or commercial content (Bonferroni-adjusted p=0.002) were more frequent post-pandemic.Pre-pandemic upload was independently associated with the provision of useful information (AOR=2.896;95% CI: 1.061-7.904),whereas a pro-vaping stance was associated with lower odds (AOR=0.081;95% CI: 0.018-0.377).Uploader category was not significantly associated with useful information (p>0.05).CONCLUSIONS Useful information was less frequent post-pandemic, whereas personal experience, entertainment, or commercial content was more frequent.These findings may represent a challenge for tobacco control on digital platforms.Uploader identity and popularity alone are insufficient indicators of usefulness or reliability.
科研通智能强力驱动
Strongly Powered by AbleSci AI