Accounting Carbonaceous Counterfeits in Graphene Materials Using the Thermogravimetric Analysis (TGA) Approach

Counterfeits in the supply chain of high-value advanced materials such as graphene and their derivatives have become a concerning problem with a potential negative impact on this growing and emerging industry. Recent studies have revealed alarming facts that a large percentage of manufactured graphene materials on market are not graphene, raising considerable concerns for the end users. The common and recommended methods for the characterization of graphene materials, such as transmission electron microscopy (TEM), atomic force microscopy (AFM), and Raman spectroscopy based on spot analysis and probing properties of individual graphene particles, are limited to provide the determination of the properties of "bulk" graphene powders at a large scale and the identification of non-graphene components or purposely included additives. These limitations are creating counterfeit opportunities by adding low-cost black carbonaceous materials into manufactured graphene powders. To address this problem, it is critical to have reliable characterization methods, which can probe the specific properties of graphene powders at bulk scale, confirm their typical graphene signature, and detect the presence of unwanted additional compounds, where the thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) method is one of the most promising methods to perform this challenging task. This paper presents the evaluation of the TGA method and its ability to detect low-cost carbon additives such as graphite, carbon black, biochar, and activated carbon as potential counterfeiting materials to graphene materials and their derivatives such as graphene oxide (GO) and reduced GO. The superior performance of the TGA method is demonstrated here, showing its excellent capability to successfully detect these additives when mixed with graphene materials, which is not possible by two other comparative methods (Raman spectroscopy and powder X-ray diffraction (XRD)), which are used as the common characterization methods for graphene materials.