Selective dechlorination of organic chlorides over hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) remains a challenge because of their coincidence. Nanoscale zerovalent iron (nFe0) draws a promising picture of in situ groundwater dechlorination, but its indiscriminate reactivity limits the application. Here, nFe0 crystals are designed with electron shuttles and improved hydrophobic nature based on elemental chalcophile-siderophile characteristics, where chalcophile-siderophile S served as a bridge to allow impregnating nFe0 crystals with weakly siderophile and strongly chalcophile Cu. Even impregnations of lattice chalcophile-siderophile elements into the nFe0 crystals are evidenced at both intraparticle and individual-particle levels. The modulated Fe microenvironment and physicochemical properties broke the reactivity-selectivity-longevity-stability trade-off. Compared to nFe0, superhydrophobic Cu─S─nFe0 with lattice expansion promoted dechlorination by 20-fold but inhibited HER by 150-fold, utilizing ≈80-100% electrons from the Fe0 reservoir. This work demonstrates the concept of engineering nFe0 lattice with tunable structure-property relationships, mimicking reductive dehalogenases by selectively interacting with halocarbon functional groups for efficient dehalogenation and sustainable groundwater remediation.