作者
S. M. Kumta,Alex Pak Lik Tsang,Leung Kim Hung,Jack C. Y. Cheng
摘要
Purpose. To study the performance of final year medical students, at the end of module assessments, following exposure to a web-based tutorial programme designed to facilitate critical thinking and logical reasoning. Method. Multimedia enhanced web-based tutorials based on patient oriented problems, designed to develop higher cognitive skills in students, were used as a supplement to an existing curricular programme for final year medical students attending an orthopaedic surgery rotation. We tested this intervention in a group of 163 final year medical students. Clusters of 15 students were randomly assigned either to an intervention or a control group. Students were examined for their clinical examination skills, critical thinking abilities, and specific factual knowledge based on curricular requirements. Results. Mean scores between control and intervention group were analyzed, and the intervention group outperformed the control group (Statistically Significant). Conclusion. Interactive web-based tutorial programmes can be successfully designed to develop higher cognitive skills in medical students. This results in more sound clinical decision making skills than simple noninteractive, content-rich web resources. ********** Jl. of Educational Multimedia and Hypermedia (2003) 12(3), 267-273 Clinicians across all disciplines are facing the difficulty of filtering large quantities of information and determining, which is based on evidence, in order to make safe and accurate management decisions. Although evidence-based decision support tools provide relevant and up-to-date evidence to clinicians, actual integration of the new information into practice is a function of experience. That is, interpretation and use of evidence as opposed to hypotheses depends on prior knowledge and experience of the clinician (Allen, Arocha, & Patel, 1998). In this aspect, undergraduate medical students are at a disadvantage as they are inundated with information that often, they are unable to use in a logical, analytical manner. Conventional lecture based curricula are not well designed to develop such analytical thinking and problem-solving skills. The problem of information overload is especially severe in medical subspecialties, in which there is limited time and exposure allowed for any given subspecialty, through which medical students rotate in any academic year. Imparting practically relevant knowledge therefore needs to be done within short teaching modules. Without critical thinking ability, the student may not be able to use available information well. Consequently students have expressed difficulty in understanding the applicability of subspecialty content for general medical practice. As a group of teachers in charge of planning the Orthopaedic curriculum for final year medical students, we strongly felt the need to implement a teaching strategy that would enhance learning and inculcate critical thinking abilities in students, without subjecting them to an information overload. We made use of a computer-based multimedia course for final year medical students doing their Orthopaedic rotation, that was comprised of a series of self-navigated problems designed to stimulate critical thinking and logical reasoning. We then compared the use of this intervention with the conventional lecture based didactic method of teaching in a randomized controlled study. METHODS During their Senior Surgical Clerkship, final year medical students attend a 3-week module with the Department of Orthopaedics, in 11 groups of 14-15 students, spread over the academic year. As part of this project, clusters of 15 students were randomly assigned either to a Study or to a Control group during their attachment to our department. A preintervention test comprised of multiple-choice questions was administered to both groups at the beginning of their module. …