Structure–Selectivity Relationship Prediction of Tau Imaging Tracers Using Machine Learning-Assisted QSAR Models and Interaction Fingerprint Map

Protein aggregates composed of tau fibrils are major pathologic findings in different tauopathies. An ideal agent for imaging tau fibrils must be highly selective. The molecular basis for the binding of current available compounds to tau aggregates is not well understood. Herein, we provide insights into previously studied positron emission tomography tracers using various computational methods, including machine learning-based quantitative structure-activity relationship (QSAR) classification, docking, and molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to investigate the structural basis of selective tau aggregate binding for potential compounds. The QSAR classification model based on the Random Forest algorithm with an accuracy of 96.6% for the selective and 97.6% for the nonselective class of compounds revealed essential selective moieties. The combination of molecular docking, MD simulations, and molecular mechanics Poisson-Boltzmann surface area (MM/PBSA) binding free-energy calculation showed superior binding energy of ligand 63 toward tau and PHF6, a key hexapeptide in tau aggregation, as the most selective compound in the data set. Dissecting the binding properties of ligand 63 and ligand 8 (the least selective compound) within tau and Aβ structures confirmed that these two compounds favor different binding sites of tau; however, the preferential binding site in Aβ was similar for both with lower binding energies calculated for ligand 8. Results revealed that the number of N-heterocycles, the position of nitrogen atoms, and the presence of tertiary amine are important components of selective binding moieties, and they should be maintained in molecules for selective binding to tau aggregates. The predicted structure-selectivity relationship will facilitate the rational design and further development of selective tau imaging agents.