We investigate a novel Marangoni-induced instability that arises exclusively in diffuse fluid interfaces, that is absent in classical sharp-interface models. Using a validated phase-field Navier–Stokes–Allen–Cahn framework, we linearise the governing equations to analyse the onset and development of interfacial instability driven by solute-induced surface tension gradients. A critical interfacial thickness scaling inversely with the Marangoni number, $\delta _{\textit{cr}} \sim \textit{Ma}^{-1}$ , emerges from the balance between advective and diffusive transport. Unlike sharp-interface scenarios where matched viscosity and diffusivity stabilise the interface, finite thickness induces asymmetric solute distributions and tangential velocity shifts that destabilise the system. We identify universal power-law scalings of velocity and concentration offsets with a modified Marangoni number $\textit{Ma}_\delta$ , independent of capillary number and interfacial mobility. A critical crossover at $ \textit{Ma}_\delta \approx 590$ distinguishes diffusion-dominated stabilisation from advection-driven destabilisation. These findings highlight the importance of diffuse-interface effects in multiphase flows, with implications for miscible fluids, soft matter, and microfluidics where interfacial thickness and coupled transport phenomena are non-negligible.