Abstract As AI capabilities advance, concerns about human cognitive decline are increasingly framed as a direct consequence of model performance. This paper argues that the risk of cognitive collapse is not driven by capability itself, but by interaction architecture. Current deployment patterns largely follow a delegation model, where AI generates outputs and human verification is optional. This structure incentivizes cognitive offloading, reduces engagement, and leads to measurable degradation in judgment and reasoning over time. In contrast, recognition-based systems enforce participation during the reasoning process. By requiring human interpretation, reconstruction, and synthesis alongside AI outputs, these architectures transform AI from a substitution mechanism into a cognitive amplification system. Drawing on empirical signals from education, software engineering, and decision-support environments, this paper demonstrates that identical models can produce opposite outcomes depending on whether cognition is optional or structurally enforced. It introduces enforcement-oriented components—including coherence-based evaluation, multi-model divergence, and constraint-governed reasoning environments—as viable pathways for maintaining human cognitive integrity in AI systems. The central claim is that cognitive outcomes are architectural, not inevitable. Systems that make thinking optional will, over time, train users not to think. Systems that require participation will amplify human reasoning. The future of AI will not be determined by model capability alone, but by whether system design requires humans to remain active participants in the reasoning process.