Diffusion Limit and the Reactivity/Affinity Conundrum: Implications for Optimization and Hit Finding for Irreversible Modulators

Irreversible inhibition as a therapeutic modality has come of age over the previous decade. With minimal theoretical guidance for the design of an irreversible modulator, empirical optimization efforts often involve increasing the affinity of the small molecule while reducing the reactivity of the electrophile. The latter, as per prevalent opinion, is to ensure that binding dictates engagement and the reactive electrophile does not pose a safety liability arising from off-target reactivity. Here I argue that, like the second-order kinetic rate constant kcat/Km, the parameter kinact/KI is limited by the upper physical limit imposed by the rate of diffusion. This capping ensures that any attempt to improve the affinity of the electrophile-containing small-molecule at the limit will come with an equivalent trade-off in their reactivity. This has implications for both hit finding and lead optimization within targeted irreversible inhibition, especially for intractable targets with shallow pockets where the interactions are collision-induced second-order processes.