It has been widely accepted that a chemically altered, protective surface layer regulates the dissolution, and hence the weathering, of plagioclase feldspars under Earth's surface conditions. In this study, we examine this hypothesis in detail with the aid of scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS). Using these techniques, we have been unable to find any direct evidence suggesting the presence of a chemically altered coating on feldspar surfaces which have been weathered in the lab. Instead, our results suggest that the mechanism controlling feldspar weathering is a surface controlled reaction. Based on SEM observations and measurements of rate of release of silica, we postulate that the process of feldspar dissolution proceeds in two stages in the lab. Initially, one observes the dissolution of ultrafine (⪡ 1 μm diameter) particles which are produced during grinding of the sample, and which adhere tenaciously to the surfaces of larger grains. This is the stage which results in the non-linear rates of dissolution which are commonly observed in the lab (parabolic kinetics). Secondly, the dissolution occurs at sites of excess surface energy such as at dislocations or similar crystal defects. This process yields linear rates of dissolution, and it dominates the weathering of feldspars in the field.