Divergent responses of soil organic carbon accumulation to 14 years of nitrogen addition in two typical subtropical forests

Developing an understanding of the response of soil organic carbon (SOC) to N addition is critical to quantify and predict the terrestrial carbon uptake under increasing N deposition in the future. However, results from field studies on the response of SOC content and composition to N addition are highly variable across different ecosystems. The interpretation of SOC responses to N addition are often complicated by the differences in climate, soil substrate and other factors. To address this question, we measured SOC and its components in adjacent broadleaved and coniferous subtropical forests after 14 years of N addition. SOC in the top 50 cm increased by 2.1 kg m-2, 1.8 kg m-2 and 1.2 kg m-2 for low, medium and high rates of N addition in the broadleaved forest, but did not change significantly in the coniferous forest. Increased SOC in the broadleaved forest was contributed by the significant increases in particulate organic carbon (POC), humus organic carbon (HOC) in the 0-10 cm and 30-50 cm soil layers and resistant organic carbon (ROC) in the 0-10 cm soil layer. 13C nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectra of coarse SOC revealed a decrease in easily decomposed carbon (C) and a shift in recalcitrant C. The increased SOC accumulation in the broadleaved forest was largely driven by altered rates of organic matter decomposition, rather than C inputs to soil. Land-history and low nutrient availability may have contributed to the lack of significant impact of N addition on SOC in the coniferous forest. Our results suggested the different controls of SOC accumulation and less sensitivity of SOC chemical composition at the molecular level to N addition in the two subtropical forest soils.