The purpose of this study is two-fold. First, we examined a potential antecedent and consequences of informal leadership emergence in teams. Second, we investigated how the interaction between multiple sources of team leadership shapes individual-level work outcomes for informal team leaders. We hypothesized that role breadth self-efficacy predicts informal leadership emergence, which in turns predicts higher individual job performance but lower job satisfaction. In addition, we hypothesized an interactive effect of formal leadership (i.e., external leadership assistance) on the relationship between informal leadership emergence and both individual-level job performance and satisfaction. We used a multilevel model and multisource data to test our hypotheses in a sample of 58 Taiwanese work teams from three organizations, each of which had a different team context (administrative, public relations, and research and development). Our results provide support for all of our hypotheses. Moreover, our findings highlight the utility of research that investigates individual-level factors that predict informal leadership emergence as well as demonstrates a synergistic effect of vertical and shared leadership on individual outcomes for informal team leaders.