We propose two different models of government subsidy mechanisms in a scenario that considers consumers' fairness concerns: the government only subsidizes enterprises for their corporate social responsibility efforts (E-strategy), and the government not only subsidizes enterprises for their social responsibility efforts but also subsidizes consumers with consumption coupons (CE-strategy). We introduce the government as the decision-making subject to analyze and compare the impact of two different subsidy strategies on the supply chain. The results indicate that (1) government subsidies are effective only if the enterprises' CSR efforts satisfy certain conditions; (2) when the coefficient of consumers' fairness concerns is small (λ < λ CE ), the government tends to adopt the E-strategy, consumers fairness concerns always exert a detrimental impact on the supply chain, and government subsidies can adjust this impact to enterprises; (3) when the coefficient of consumers' fairness concerns is larger (λ > λ CE ), the overall social benefit brought by CE-strategy is more significant; (4) different subsidy strategies bring different regulatory effects, the government can choose its subsidy strategy according to the focus of the overall social utility or the regulatory effect on the market.