Disordered mackinawite (FeSm) plays a critical role in arsenic sequestration in sulfidic environments. However, its structural evolution and the resulting impact on the variability of arsenic sorption behavior remain unexplored. Iron and arsenic K-edge X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS) was employed to investigate FeSm aging effects on arsenic sorption across pH 4.9-9.1 at an arsenic concentration of 1 mM. Iron K-edge XAS reveals that aging promotes defect healing and particle growth of FeSm. Concurrently, arsenic removal efficiency declines, with the extent varying with pH and arsenic species. Over a 60-day aging period, As(III) removal remains nearly complete at pH 4.9, but the percent removal decreases from 8.3% to 3.3% at pH 7.1 and from 6.5% to 6.0% at pH 9.1. In contrast, As(V) removal efficiency decreases under all pH conditions (e.g., from 7.4% to 4.0% at pH 4.9). Arsenic K-edge XAS shows that, at acidic-to-neutral pH, aging promotes zerovalent arsenic (As(0)) formation over arsenic sulfides due to decreased FeSm solubility and enhanced metallic conductivity. At basic pH, arsenic initially forms surface complexes, but prolonged aging favors As(0) formation. These results challenge the conventional view of FeSm as a static sorbent and highlight its dynamic nature, providing insights for improving its long-term effectiveness.