Experimental study of hydraulic fracture initiation and propagation in deep shale with different injection methods

Deep shale gas reservoirs, compared to shallow and intermediate shale gas reservoirs, usually exhibit lower fracture complexity, smaller stimulated volume, poorer conductivity, and faster production decline when the same injection scheme and construction parameters are used. As a result, specific injection scenarios for deep shale reservoirs must be investigated. In this paper, a series of laboratory fracturing tests were conducted to investigate the influence of injection scenarios on deep shale hydraulic fracture initiation and propagation. The black shale of the Lower Silurian Longmaxi formation in the Sichuan Basin was adopted, and four different injection schemes (constant fluid rate injection, cyclic injection, shut-in intermittent injection, and low-frequency pulse pressurization injection) were utilized in these experiments. The energy evolution during hydraulic fracturing with different injection schemes was analyzed by an array of acoustic emission (AE) sensors. Furthermore, the internal fracture geometry of the shale specimens after failure was determined using high-resolution CT scanning. Two parameters, fracture bulk density and fractal dimension were defined to quantitatively characterize the post-pressure fracture complexity. The results indicate that the rock breakdown pressure rises rapidly as the injection rate increases, for conventional monotonic rate injection. Although increasing the injection rate can serve the purpose of increasing the net pressure in the seam and enhancing the fracture complexity, it makes it easier to approach the equipment pressure limit. Unlike conventional hydraulic fracturing, which mainly induces tensile fractures near the wellbore, cyclic fracturing is more likely to cause fatigue damage to the rock, resulting in the formation of subcritical microcracks, which gradually grow into macroscale fractures. In addition, the cyclic injection method can reduce the rock breakdown pressure by approximately 24% compared with the conventional continuous injection method. The shut-in intermittent injection method can also reduce the breakdown pressure of shale by 22%, but this method is not conducive to enhancing the fracture complexity. Pulse fracturing creates the most complex fracture morphology among the four injection schemes tested. The rapid changes in wellbore pressure over a short time can easily result in the formation of multiple fractures around the borehole. Our experimental results and theoretical analysis can provide theoretical support for the optimization of injection schemes for deep shale hydraulic fracturing.