Screening for Adverse Childhood Experiences: A Critical Appraisal

Adverse childhood experiences (ACEs) are common and can impact health across the life course. Thus, it is essential for professionals in child- and family-serving roles, including pediatric and adult primary care clinicians, to understand the health implications of childhood adversity and trauma and respond appropriately. Screening for ACEs in health care settings has received attention as a potential approach to ACEs identification and response. Careful examination of the existing evidence on ACEs screening and consideration, from a clinical and ethical perspective, of the potential benefits, challenges, and harms is critical to ensuring evidence-informed practice. In this critical appraisal, we synthesize existing systematic and scoping reviews on ACEs screening, summarize recent studies on the ability of ACEs to predict health outcomes at the individual level, and provide a comprehensive overview of potential benefits, challenges, and harms of ACEs screening. We identify gaps in the existing evidence base and specify directions for future research. We also describe trauma-informed, relational care as an orientation and perspective that can help pediatric and primary care clinicians to sensitively assess for and respond to ACEs and other potentially traumatic experiences. Overall, we do not yet have sufficient evidence regarding the potential benefits, challenges, and harms of ACEs screening in health care and other settings. In the absence of this evidence, we cannot assume that screening will not cause harm and that potential benefits outweigh potential harms.