This study presents a controlled hydrothermal pathway for valorizing wheat straw through carbonization (HTC), humification (HTH), and fulvification (HTF) by systematically varying temperature and alkalinity. Increasing alkalinity and temperature promoted depolymerization and solubilization of lignocellulosic structures, enabling a continuous transition from solid-dominated to liquid-dominated product regimes. HTC produced the highest solid yield (67.5%) and carbon recovery (77.9%), but generated high levels of furfural and 5-hydroxymethylfurfural (HMF). Compared with HTC, HTH and HTF strongly suppressed furanic and phenolic compounds, with furfural and HMF reduced to <5 mg/kg DM and total aromatics decreased by >70% in solids and >90% in liquids. HTF reduced solid yield to 3.3% while maximizing the solubility of lactic acid (37.5 g/L) and formic acid (14.6 g/L). At 180 °C, HTF yielded substantially higher liquid-phase total organic carbon (TOC) of 50.66 g/L than HTC (16.03 g/L) and HTH (42.51 g/L). Within HTF, increasing temperature from 180 to 220 °C further enhanced carbon solubilization, with liquid-phase TOC increasing by ~32% to 66.84 g/L, indicating intensified conversion of lignocellulosic carbon into soluble organic products, in contrast to HTC and HTH, where increasing temperature led to a decrease in liquid-phase carbon content. Spectroscopic and thermal analyses showed humic- and fulvic-like structures with enhanced thermal stability at higher alkalinity. These findings show that process tuning enables targeted biomass conversion into energy-rich hydrochar via conventional HTC or more homogeneous, nutrient- and carbon-rich liquid products via HTF, opening new opportunities for agriculture and liquid-phase biorefinery research.