医学
七氟醚
麻醉
经济影响分析
基线(sea)
经济成本
重症监护医学
间接成本
成本效益分析
医疗保健
环境影响评价
挥发性麻醉剂
全身麻醉
作者
Florence Van Belleghem,Steffen Rex,An Teunkens,Hugo E. M. Vereecke,Alain Frederic Kalmar
标识
DOI:10.1097/eja.0000000000002342
摘要
BACKGROUND: Total intravenous anaesthesia (TIVA) is widely recognised as a less environmentally harmful alternative to volatile anaesthesia. However, TIVA is often perceived as a more expensive technique, raising questions about its cost-effectiveness in routine practice. OBJECTIVE: This study models the environmental impact and cost-effectiveness of TIVA versus sevoflurane anaesthesia. DESIGN: Retrospective simulation-based observational study. PATIENTS: Surgical cases of 11 909 consecutive patients, older than 5 years, observed in a tertiary Belgian hospital. INTERVENTION: The economic cost and carbon dioxide equivalent (CO 2 e) emissions of maintenance using sevoflurane versus propofol of anaesthesia were calculated, using local tender prices and the lifecycle assessment for all drugs and disposable materials involved in each scenario. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE: The economic cost and CO 2 e emissions of different scenarios for maintenance of anaesthesia. RESULTS: For every 1000 procedures, CO 2 e emissions and costs were: TIVA - 963 kg at a cost of €4300; minimal-flow sevoflurane - 25 562 kg at a cost of €6772; sevoflurane [2 l min -1 fresh gas flow (FGF)] - 59 483 kg at a cost of €11 933. CONCLUSION: Our simulations indicate that minimal flow sevoflurane produces 26.5 times more CO 2 e than TIVA, rising to 61.8 times more at 2 l min -1 FGF. TIVA also costs significantly less, at 36% and 63% of sevoflurane anaesthesia costs with minimal flow and 2 l min -1 FGF, respectively.These findings highlight not only TIVA's marked superiority in reducing carbon emissions but also its notable cost advantages over traditional volatile anaesthetic methods. The stark contrast in emissions - where TIVA produces just a fraction of the CO 2 e compared to even the most environmentally conscious sevoflurane protocols - underscores the critical role anaesthetic choice plays in healthcare sustainability. Moreover, the substantial difference in costs challenges the prevailing perception that TIVA is prohibitively expensive. As hospitals worldwide face mounting pressure to align clinical practices with environmental stewardship, these results advocate for a critical reassessment of routine anaesthetic protocols.
科研通智能强力驱动
Strongly Powered by AbleSci AI