A universal criterion for underwater gas bubble stability

The stability of underwater bubbles is important to many natural phenomena and industrial applications. Since stability analyses are complex and influenced by numerous factors, they are often performed on a case-specific basis, with most being qualitative. In this work, we propose a unified and quantitative criterion for evaluating bubble stability by analysing its free energy. This criterion is broadly applicable across various bubble sizes (from nanometres to macroscale) and contact conditions (suspended, attached and trapped bubbles) on surfaces with diverse chemical (hydrophilic and hydrophobic) and morphological (flat and structured solid surfaces) features. This criterion not only applies to the classical stable bubble mode, which depends on contact line pinning at the tips of surface structures, but also predicts a new mode where the synergy between the geometry and wettability of the sidewalls maintains the bubble’s stable state. The contact line can spontaneously adjust its position on the solid surface to maintain pressure balance, which enhances bubble adaptability to environmental changes. A geometric standard for solid surfaces supporting this new stable state is raised, following which we realise the optimisation of solid surface geometries to control the stability of gas bubbles. This work not only provides a universal framework for understanding underwater bubble stability, but also opens avenues for applications.