观察研究
科研诚信
医学
科学不端行为
冲击系数
出版偏见
梅德林
编辑部
家庭医学
心理学
研究伦理
强制性报告
图书馆学
学术诚信
弱势群体
样板文本
出版
伦理委员会
作者
Andrew B. Grey,Alison Avenell,Mark J Bolland
标识
DOI:10.1080/08989621.2026.2671154
摘要
BACKGROUND: Early notification of journal readers of the existence of publication integrity concerns by an editorial expression of concern (EoC) can mitigate the adverse effects of unreliable research. METHODS: We extracted EoCs and retraction notices from the Retraction Watch database up until the end of 2024. We assessed temporal trends in publication of each notice, the proportion of retracted papers with an associated EoC, and the timing of EoCs according to publication date and retraction status. We examined the ratio of EoCs to retractions among authors, including those with multiple retractions, and among both journals and publishers. RESULTS: EoCs were rarely published during the 14y assessment period. Only 3.3% of retracted papers had a preceding EoC. For 56% of publications with an EoC, the EoC was the latest notice. 92% of authors had an EoC:retraction ratio < 1. Only 35% of authors with > 5 retractions had an EoC, and 99% had an EoC:retraction ratio < 1. Publication of an EoC was more common in journals which had published > 5 retractions than in those which had published < 5. CONCLUSIONS: EoCs are rarely employed during the assessment of publication integrity concerns. Journal readers are disadvantaged by delayed notification of potentially unreliable research.
科研通智能强力驱动
Strongly Powered by AbleSci AI