Numerical characterizations of the thermomechanical response of power modules with ceramic substrates and lead-free bonds

Purpose The present paper aims to study the influence of the substrate system on the thermomechanical response of various lead-free die attach materials used in power electronics using nonlinear finite element simulations. Design/methodology/approach Particularly, three ceramic substrate systems, including direct copper bonded (DCB) and aluminum nitride (AlN) – as well as silicon nitride (Si3N4) –based insulated metal substrate (IMS) configurations are examined in this study. Additionally, three die attach systems, namely, silver-tin transient liquid phase (TLP), sintered silver (Ag) and sintered copper (Cu) are included in the analysis. ANSYS software is employed to build the finite element models of the power modules and to conduct the nonlinear thermomechanical investigations. Findings The simulation results revealed that the IMS, Si3N4 and DCB-based power modules end up with significantly lower interconnect inelastic strains and inelastic strain energies suggesting better fatigue life performance. Additionally, the bonding layer stresses and expected failure mechanism are not influenced by the substrate configuration rather than the bond material. For instance, the silver-tin TLP joints develop high stresses and hence brittle failures are expected. Nonetheless, the sintered Ag and sintered Cu have significantly lower stresses which could lead to fatigue-induced failures. Originality/value Power electronics use various ceramic-based substrate systems because of their improved thermal conductivity, electrical insulation and heat resistance properties. The proper selection of the substrate structure could highly enhance the thermal fatigue of the power modules. Markedly, the findings of this research are useful for designing highly reliable and effective power modules continuously subjected to thermomechanical loadings.