判断
心理学
基础(证据)
光学(聚焦)
终身学习
认知心理学
数学教育
教育学
定性研究
注重形式
芯(光纤)
语言习得
元认知
教学方法
价值判断
同行反馈
评价方法
定性性质
构造(python库)
纠正性反馈
高等教育
形成性评价
社会心理学
第二语言写作
作者
Shijun Cindy Chen,Jessica To
标识
DOI:10.1080/02602938.2026.2711099
摘要
Making evaluative judgments is a core lifelong learning capacity and the foundation of student feedback literacy. However, its development in second language (L2) writing remains underexplored. This qualitative case study investigated how 28 undergraduates developed evaluative judgement through comparison of essay drafts with exemplars, AI feedback and their goals in three writing tasks throughout a 14-week semester. Data sources included students’ self-reflection forms, semi-structured interviews, initial and revised essay drafts. Findings showed that through iterative comparison, their evaluation focus expanded from language features to higher-order aspects of writing (content, organisation, and coherence), but their evaluative reasoning lacked sophistication. Three types of evaluators (reconstructive; language-focused; criteria-compliance) were identified to illustrate their differing evaluative judgement orientations, developmental pathways, and ways of using internal feedback to formulate academic judgments. Implications for evaluative judgement-related pedagogical and research designs are outlined.
科研通智能强力驱动
Strongly Powered by AbleSci AI